2025A&A...699A.151S


Query : 2025A&A...699A.151S

2025A&A...699A.151S - Astronomy and Astrophysics, volume 699A151 (2025/7-1)

Testing gravity with wide binaries 3D velocities and distances of wide binaries from Gaia and HARPS.

SAGLIA R., PASQUINI L., PATAT F., LUDWIG H.-G., GIRIBALDI R., LEAO I., DE MEDEIROS J.R. and MURPHY M.T.

Abstract (from CDS):

Context. Wide binaries (WBs) are interesting systems to test Newton-Einstein gravity in low potentials. The basic concept is to verify whether the difference in velocity between the WB components is compatible with what is expected from the Newton law.
Aims. Previous attempts, based solely on Gaia proper motion differences scaled to transverse velocity differences using mean parallax distances, do not provide conclusive results. Here we add to the Gaia transverse velocities precise measurements of the third velocity component, the radial velocity (RV), in order to identify multiple stars and improve the reliability of the test by using velocity differences and positions in three dimensions.
Methods. We mined the ESO archive for observations of WBs with the high precision HARPS spectrograph, and we used these observations to search for RV variations, that indicate the presence of additional stars in the system. We used the HARPS spectra to determine accurate RV differences between the WB components while also correcting the observed velocities for gravitational redshift and convective shift. We exploited the Gaia distance distributions to determine the projected and intrinsic separations s and r and the three-dimensional velocity differences of the binaries.
Results. We retrieved 44 pairs observed with HARPS, most of them with numerous observations, spanning time baselines from one week to several years. A considerable fraction (27%) of these pairs show signs of multiplicity or are not suitable for the test, and 32 bona fide WBs survived our selection. Their projected separation, s, is up to 14 kAU, or 0.06 parsec. The median renormalized unit weight error parameter for the final sample is 0.975, highest value 1.24, and the median RV variability is 10 m s–1 with a standard deviation of 6 m s–1. Gaia RVs are on average smaller by only 68 m s–1 from those determined with HARPS, with an RMS dispersion of 311 m s–1. We determined the distances, eccentricities, and position angles to reproduce the velocity differences according to Newton's law, finding reasonable solutions for all WBs but one, and some systems are possibly too near pericenter and/or at too high inclination. Conclusions. We show that precise (and accurate) multiple RVs of WB candidates are a very powerful tool to make the WBs test of gravity more robust and reliable. These observations allow one to minimize or eliminate one of the major limitations of previous tests, that is, the presence of multiple systems, and make the comparison with theory straightforward, without the need to resort to complex simulations. Our (limited) number of WBs does not show obvious trends with separation or acceleration and is consistent with Newtonian dynamics. We are currently collecting a larger sample of this kind to robustly assess these results.

Abstract Copyright: © The Authors 2025

Journal keyword(s): astrometry - parallaxes - proper motions - binaries: general - stars: distances - stars: kinematics and dynamics

Simbad objects: 83

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 83
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 CD-26 16866B * 00 00 09.8310028968 -25 19 20.935437096   9.913 9.442 10.125   ~ 6 0
2 HD 2567 PM* 00 29 16.1106115680 -05 54 37.760587056   8.40 7.76     G1V 68 0
3 HD 2638 ** 00 29 59.8721784936 -05 45 50.396133276   10.33 9.38 9.10 9.19 K1V 108 1
4 HD 4552 PM* 00 47 41.1613326792 +12 52 45.408055116   9.45 8.91     F8 23 0
5 BD+12 90 PM* 00 47 43.6451376936 +12 52 19.761928788   9.80 9.18     G0 21 0
6 G 70-50 PM* 01 18 40.2176935638 -00 52 27.818522640   12.13 10.679 9.821 9.01 K7Ve 60 0
7 HD 7895 ** 01 18 41.0986391699 -00 52 03.237437701   9.19 8.68 8.75   K1V 104 0
8 CD-50 524 PM* 01 52 25.5552506832 -49 32 03.183610236   9.80 9.22     ~ 16 0
9 HD 11584 PM* 01 52 27.5724524088 -49 31 25.549969872   9.60 9.08     F6/8V 26 0
10 HD 11783 PM* 01 56 01.1603873520 +18 26 44.591249148   8.76 8.31     F2 12 1
11 HD 13357B PM* 02 10 51.7147156872 +13 40 57.136123452   9.57 8.81     G8V 26 0
12 HD 13357A PM* 02 10 52.0806000541 +13 40 59.802324665   8.88 8.20 8.75   G4V 105 0
13 HD 13904 SB* 02 15 42.2976125184 +10 46 15.646339740   10.05 9.48     G0 24 0
14 V* AO Ari LP? 02 55 41.2753315752 +31 02 35.151625680   8.65 6.93     M3II-III 28 0
15 HD 20430 PM* 03 17 26.3862805584 +07 39 20.919521880   7.958 7.373 7.050 6.739 F8 143 0
16 HD 20439 PM* 03 17 32.7800971992 +07 41 24.556610724   8.376 7.747 7.402 7.085 G1 150 1
17 * zet01 Ret PM* 03 17 46.1634549490 -62 34 31.152456644 6.24 6.18 5.54 5.00 4.66 G2.5VHdel1 324 0
18 * zet02 Ret ** 03 18 12.8188824117 -62 30 22.904711032   5.814 5.228     G1V 399 0
19 HD 20781 PM* 03 20 02.9428582501 -28 47 01.790465531   9.263 8.44 8.17 8.43 G9.5V 135 1
20 HD 20782 PM* 03 20 03.5777546706 -28 51 14.660358176   8.03 7.38     G1.5V 240 1
21 HD 21209B PM* 03 23 15.8895353604 -49 59 38.743504037   11.71 10.32 9.925   K8Vk: 48 0
22 HD 21209 PM* 03 23 17.1766583819 -49 59 30.913415913   9.67 8.59     K3.5V 87 0
23 MCC 428 PM* 03 43 45.2472000220 +16 40 02.166682565 13.476 12.265 10.763 9.78 8.681 M0V 96 0
24 BD+16 502 PM* 03 43 52.5642780322 +16 40 19.303290141 12.614 11.355 9.900 8.995 8.101 K6V 86 0
25 HD 24062 PM* 03 44 46.8466611744 -70 01 35.940918828   8.04 7.41     G0V 72 0
26 HD 24085 PM* 03 45 01.5501714816 -70 01 26.760507060   8.16 7.56     G0V 79 0
27 HD 26913 BY* 04 15 25.7871375264 +06 11 58.751401236 7.790 7.580 6.920 6.554 6.195 G6V 243 0
28 HD 26923 PM* 04 15 28.8004060272 +06 11 12.698572488 6.910 6.860   5.9   G0IV 236 0
29 CD-26 1686 * 04 27 49.6964667504 -26 08 35.249360496   11.02 10.45     ~ 4 0
30 Cl Melotte 25 OpC 04 30 27.4 +16 46 43           ~ 3309 0
31 HD 29167 ** 04 31 55.95 -59 52 29.5           G0V 13 0
32 HD 29167B * 04 31 56.6285779920 -59 52 26.226746292   10.63 9.96 10.064   ~ 14 0
33 HD 52491 * 07 00 02.7473795760 -31 13 41.105254800   9.20 8.44     G9V 40 0
34 HD 52516 * 07 00 09.7727137296 -31 08 30.070514832   7.05 6.61     F5.5VFe-0.7CH-0.4 45 0
35 HD 54046 PM* 07 08 00.2417408376 +15 31 42.947179536   8.36   7.5   G0V 73 0
36 HD 54100 PM* 07 08 11.9819833608 +15 31 15.052831176   8.25   7.3   F8 66 0
37 HD 84612 PM* 09 45 01.8467987328 -49 29 13.760078172   8.67 8.16     F8/G2IV/V 54 1
38 HD 84627 PM* 09 45 03.6607808400 -49 29 07.305114480   8.48 8.03     F8/G0V 71 1
39 V* FH Leo PM* 11 06 07.4166985512 +07 02 00.454480872   9.16 8.75     F8 31 0
40 AG+07 1510 PM* 11 06 07.5594387048 +07 01 52.409019144   10.91 10.14     G3V 12 0
41 HD 104760 PM* 12 03 46.2941904024 -44 07 22.106694144   8.68 8.07     G2/3III 68 0
42 HD 104759 PM* 12 03 47.7180408384 -44 07 04.678537152   9.49 8.75     G8/K0V 32 0
43 HD 106515B PM* 12 15 06.1003498656 -07 15 26.586550836   9.07 8.20     G8V 36 0
44 HD 106515A PM* 12 15 06.5667197808 -07 15 26.353003536   8.79 7.97     G5V 100 1
45 HD 116858 PM* 13 26 39.5573107894 -24 17 36.144021454   9.71 8.78     K2.5Vk: 77 0
46 HD 116920 PM* 13 27 02.9054442296 -24 17 25.568034235   9.64 8.73     K2+V 69 0
47 * alf Cen ** 14 39 36.50 -60 50 02.3   0.4 -0.1     G2V+K1V 1031 0
48 HD 133131A PM* 15 03 35.4459923952 -27 50 33.219468636   9.05 8.46 9.18   G2V 44 0
49 HD 133131B PM* 15 03 35.8080507408 -27 50 27.584310732   9.030 8.413 9.18   G2V 26 0
50 HD 135101 PM* 15 12 43.4807788693 +19 17 09.742475250   7.36   6.2   G5V_Fe-0.9 190 0
51 HD 135101B PM* 15 12 43.7765264754 +19 17 32.775938988   8.26   6.8   G7V 108 0
52 HD 143336B * 16 01 01.6965781440 -32 18 25.675519284       10.25   G 3 0
53 HD 143336 * 16 01 02.0029611792 -32 18 10.644354360   10.26 9.688     G3/5V 10 0
54 CD-29 12513B PM* 16 24 39.7581469728 -29 42 12.309749820   7.14 6.53     G0V 46 0
55 CD-29 12513A PM* 16 24 39.7741088568 -29 42 16.785116136   6.40 5.82     F9IV 51 0
56 HD 154363 PM* 17 05 03.3944309308 -05 03 59.438943094 9.945 8.881 7.709 6.985 6.364 K4/5V 247 0
57 HD 154363B PM* 17 05 13.7795704153 -05 05 39.246739252 12.571 11.486 10.071 9.101 7.958 M1.5V 197 0
58 * 36 Oph A PM* 17 15 20.7836485323 -26 36 06.117207947   5.93 5.08     K2V 293 1
59 * 36 Oph ** 17 15 20.9839376 -26 36 10.157115           K2V+K1V 145 0
60 HD 169392A SB* 18 24 42.9854204880 -06 36 13.674463524   7.98 7.41     G0IV 46 0
61 BD-10 4948B PM* 19 06 20.3733483408 -10 43 11.405100396   10.09 9.42     G5 12 0
62 HD 177730 PM* 19 06 21.1608522984 -10 43 06.546344196   10.03 9.42     G8/K0(III)+G0/2 18 0
63 HD 181544 PM* 19 22 03.8635887504 -29 31 23.027759292   7.64 7.11     G1V 49 0
64 HD 182797 PM* 19 27 24.8105097552 -26 11 58.187670432   9.91 9.33     G0V 16 0
65 HD 182817 PM* 19 27 29.5333867344 -26 12 26.727905196   9.62 9.08     F7V 9 0
66 HD 189739 * 20 01 36.9776014176 -01 40 16.542095232   9.43 8.90     G2V 22 0
67 HD 189760 * 20 01 40.6793467320 -01 40 32.098399032   9.58 9.02     K0III 15 0
68 CPD-52 11628B * 20 09 41.9233874975 -52 11 27.524101898       10.470   ~ 7 0
69 CPD-52 11628 ** 20 09 42.06696 -52 11 26.5560           ~ 2 0
70 HD 192343 PM* 20 14 09.1788534888 +06 34 37.972050888   8.66 8.02     G4V 66 0
71 HD 192344 PM* 20 14 09.7715874504 +06 35 20.319826704   8.37 7.70     G4IV 72 0
72 * mu.02 Oct PM* 20 41 44.1016298400 -75 21 02.883008592   7.05 6.44     G0V 78 1
73 HD 196068 PM* 20 41 45.5181094440 -75 20 47.046574500   7.85 7.21     G1V 65 0
74 CD-34 14724A PM* 20 55 07.9443524136 -34 08 08.007489384   10.74 10.05 10.17 9.774 F8 94 0
75 CD-34 14724B PM* 20 55 09.1576722384 -34 08 07.913816448       10.51 10.06 F9 44 0
76 HD 201247A PM* 21 10 25.3550447856 -54 34 25.479143940   8.410 7.71 8.34   G5V 12 0
77 HD 201247B PM* 21 10 25.7029745136 -54 34 28.161349032   8.64 7.93     G7V 12 0
78 HD 201796B PM* 21 12 22.3901213904 -14 59 57.728039388   8.93 8.23     G5V 16 0
79 HD 201796A PM* 21 12 22.6062076992 -15 00 00.363937788   8.83 8.17 8.77   G3V 55 0
80 HD 206429 PM* 21 43 59.0307688488 -57 19 30.891399708   6.956 6.482     F6/8IV/V 37 0
81 HD 206428 PM* 21 44 00.3754790232 -57 16 58.993629312   7.314 6.843     F5/7IV/V 37 0
82 HD 221550B PM* 23 33 20.5298805408 -47 18 09.226841256   10.51 9.88 10.01   ~ 9 0
83 HD 221550A PM* 23 33 20.5782877440 -47 18 03.343818384   10.47 9.71 9.99   ~ 8 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2025A&A...699A.151S and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu