2025A&A...700A.235H


Query : 2025A&A...700A.235H

2025A&A...700A.235H - Astronomy and Astrophysics, volume 700A235 (2025/8-1)

CAMPOS II. The onset of protostellar disk substructures and planet formation.

HSIEH C.-H., ARCE H.G., MAUREIRA M.J., PINEDA J.E., SEGURA-COX D., MARDONES D., DUNHAM M.M., LI H. and OFFNER S.S.R.

Abstract (from CDS):

The 1.3 mm CAMPOS survey has resolved 90 protostellar disks with ∼15 au resolution across the Ophiuchus, Corona Australis, and Chamaeleon star-forming regions. To address the fundamental question of when planet formation begins, we combined the CAMPOS sample with literature observations of Class 0-II disks (bolometric temperature, Tbol ≤ 1900 K), all mapped at 1.3 mm with resolutions ranging from 4 to 33 au. To investigate substructure detection rates as a function of bolometric temperature, we restricted the sample to disks observed at a wavelength of 1.3 mm, with inclinations below 75° and linear resolutions ≤20 au, and resolved with at least four resolution elements (θdisk/θres ≥ 4). We also considered the effects of extinction correction and the inclusion of Herschel Space Telescope data on the bolometric temperature measurements to constrain the lower and upper limits of bolometric temperature for each source. We find that by Tbol ∼ 200-400 K, substructure detection rates increase sharply to ∼60%, corresponding to an approximate age of 0.2-0.4 Myr. No substructures are detected in Class 0 disks. The ratio of disk-averaged brightness temperature to predicted dust temperature shows a trend of increasing values toward the youngest Class 0 disks, suggesting higher optical depths in these early stages. Our statistical analysis confirms that substructures similar to the ones in Class II disks are already common by the Class I stage, and the emergence of these structures at Tbol ∼ 200-400 K could represent only an upper limit. Classifying disks with substructures into those with and without large central cavities, we find both populations coexisting across evolutionary stages, suggesting that they are not necessarily evolutionarily linked. Suppose protostellar disk substructures do follow an evolutionary sequence. In that case, our results imply that disk substructures evolve very rapidly and thus can be present in all Class I/II stages and/or that they can be triggered at different times.

Abstract Copyright: © The Authors 2025

Journal keyword(s): methods: observational - techniques: interferometric - planet-disk interactions - stars: low-mass

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/A+A/700/A235): tablea1.dat tablea2.dat tablea3.dat>

Simbad objects: 132

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 132
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 HH 211 Y*O 03 43 56.52 +32 00 52.8           ~ 414 0
2 IRAS 04016+2610 Y*O 04 04 43.07064 +26 18 56.3904           ~ 284 0
3 LDN 1489 DNe 04 04 47.5 +26 19 42           ~ 238 0
4 NAME California Molecular Cloud MoC 04 10.0 +39 00           ~ 188 1
5 IRAS 04166+2706 Y*O 04 19 42.62736 +27 13 38.4312           ~ 153 0
6 IRAS 04169+2702 Y*O 04 19 58.44936 +27 09 57.0672           K0-M4 130 1
7 V* HL Tau Or* 04 31 38.5107609312 +18 13 57.859747968   15.89 14.49 14.39   K5 1546 0
8 IRAS 04365+2535 Y*O 04 39 35.19360 +25 41 44.7252           ~ 330 0
9 NAME Taurus Complex SFR 04 41.0 +25 52           ~ 4971 0
10 IRAS 11030-7702 TT* 11 04 22.7159038128 -77 18 08.299910700     17.89     K6/M0e 75 0
11 [PMG2001] NIR 76 Y*? 11 06 46.580 -77 22 32.56           ~ 58 0
12 NAME Cha 1 MoC 11 06 48 -77 18.0           ~ 1266 1
13 [CCE98] 2-24 Y*O 11 07 21.426 -77 22 11.76           M2 37 0
14 Ass Cha T 1-15 Or* 11 07 43.6610412264 -77 39 41.134236408   17.05 15.34   12.67 K5Ve 88 0
15 ESO-HA 562 Or* 11 08 02.8789169712 -77 38 42.580139640     17.61   14.41 M0.5+M0.5 59 0
16 V* GM Cha Or* 11 09 28.55424 -76 33 28.1376           M3.5-M6.5 56 0
17 HJM C 1-24 TT* 11 09 46.1881553592 -76 34 46.503994080   11.93 18.41   14.72 M3.25e 71 1
18 BYB 43 Or* 11 09 47.3883040248 -77 26 29.187831192         16.62 M3.25e 60 0
19 [PMK99] IR Cha INa4 Y*O 11 10 03.368 -76 33 11.13           M4: 17 0
20 HJM C 1-8 Or* 11 10 11.3918141448 -76 35 29.247545184         13.75 K5Ve 68 0
21 NAME Chamaeleon Region SFR 11 55 -78.0           ~ 887 0
22 [B2001b] IRS 2 Y*O 12 01 33.86688 -65 08 44.9232           ~ 42 0
23 [B2001b] IRS 1 Y*O 12 01 36.53040 -65 08 51.9180           ~ 167 0
24 BHR 71 MoC 12 01 37 -65 08.8           ~ 163 0
25 V* DK Cha TT* 12 53 17.2111480272 -77 07 10.736046012           F0e 149 0
26 NAME Cha II MoC 12 54 -77.2           ~ 361 0
27 2MASS J12534285-7715114 Y*O 12 53 42.856 -77 15 11.48           M6.5 23 0
28 2MASS J12590656-7707401 Y*O 12 59 06.56 -77 07 40.1           K4.5 51 0
29 CD-40 8434 TT* 14 08 10.1545500744 -41 23 52.573291080   13.42 12.18 11.71 10.506 K7IVe 546 0
30 Lupus 1 Cld 15 43 02.1 -34 09 06           ~ 320 0
31 IRAS 15398-3359 Y*? 15 43 02.21016 -34 09 07.7112       18.38 21.72 ~ 215 0
32 V* GW Lup Or* 15 46 44.7290527536 -34 30 35.677420056   13.8       M1.5e 201 0
33 HD 142666 TT* 15 56 40.0221861696 -22 01 40.005872148 9.41 9.37 8.82 8.31 8.01 F0V_sh 306 0
34 V* RU Lup TT* 15 56 42.3108692112 -37 49 15.473946900 9.27 10.07 9.60     K7/M0e 528 0
35 HD 143006 Or* 15 58 36.9126279888 -22 57 15.220559196   10.92 10.14   8.70 G5IVe 338 0
36 WRAY 15-1400 TT* 15 59 16.4717314824 -41 57 10.300018176   13.5 12.0     K7IVe 125 0
37 V* V935 Sco Or* 16 22 18.5331624192 -23 21 48.146194512   13.6 12.67     K4 51 0
38 ATO J246.2787-23.8474 Y*O 16 25 06.9166702512 -23 50 50.347017132           M3 24 0
39 EM* SR 22 Or* 16 25 24.3512329440 -24 29 44.379021480       14.52 12.88 M0e 74 0
40 BKLT J162538-242238 Or* 16 25 38.1274773528 -24 22 36.185318004           M0 45 0
41 ** RAT 2B * 16 25 38.1427824096 -24 22 38.375116068           ~ 6 0
42 BKLT J162546-242337 BD? 16 25 46.62912 -24 23 36.1104           ~ 12 0
43 EM* SR 4 Or* 16 25 56.1659023848 -24 20 48.240627072     12.80 11.7 10.7 K0:Ve 216 1
44 GSS 26 Y*O 16 26 10.33152 -24 20 54.8232           M0 94 1
45 CRBR 2315.8-1700 Y*O 16 26 17.22936 -24 23 45.3660           ~ 47 0
46 Elia 2-20 TT* 16 26 18.8775818016 -24 28 19.695035064           ~ 140 1
47 GSS 30 Y*O 16 26 21.38160 -24 23 04.0524           ~ 223 1
48 [CHG85] GSS 30 IRS 3 Y*O 16 26 21.77376 -24 22 51.3948           ~ 79 0
49 [GY92] 21 Y*O 16 26 23.57976 -24 24 39.4956           K7 80 2
50 DoAr 25 TT* 16 26 23.6911292736 -24 43 13.888543800       12.65   K5 201 0
51 Elia 2-24 TT* 16 26 24.0886188024 -24 16 13.448569260   16.3 14.40 15.81 13.97 K6 208 1
52 [GY92] 30 Y*O 16 26 25.48920 -24 23 01.5576           ~ 52 0
53 GBS-VLA J162626.31-242430.2 Y*O 16 26 26.31 -24 24 30.7           ~ 22 0
54 [HCL2018] VLA 1623Ab smm 16 26 26.3847 -24 24 30.854           ~ 11 0
55 GBS-VLA J162626.39-242430.9 Y*O 16 26 26.39 -24 24 30.8           ~ 38 0
56 [HCL2018] VLA 1623Aa smm 16 26 26.3981 -24 24 30.807           ~ 11 0
57 [GY92] 33 Y*O 16 26 27.5391054120 -24 41 53.887865712           ~ 36 0
58 HGBS J162627.6-242359 cor 16 26 27.60 -24 23 55.0           ~ 75 0
59 BKLT J162636-241554 Or* 16 26 36.8350696008 -24 15 51.854365512       17.37 15.67 K7-M1 48 1
60 [GY92] 91 Y*O 16 26 40.46952 -24 27 14.4720           ~ 92 1
61 VSSG 30 Y*O 16 26 44.19504 -24 34 48.3492           ~ 138 0
62 GSS 39 Or* 16 26 45.0318401664 -24 23 07.793180124           M0 255 1
63 BBRCG 6 Y*O 16 26 48.39672 -24 28 34.8852           ~ 12 1
64 WL 2 Y*O 16 26 48.48624 -24 28 38.9064           ~ 64 1
65 WL 18 TT* 16 26 48.9809680488 -24 38 25.152593208       19.33 17.38 M3.5 77 0
66 BKLT J162656-241353 TT* 16 26 56.7836190744 -24 13 51.537326592       18.46 16.29 K7 40 0
67 EM* SR 24A TT* 16 26 58.5134422944 -24 45 36.722580480       14.15 12.87 K1 118 0
68 WL 16 Y*O 16 27 02.33520 -24 37 27.2316           A0-F3 164 0
69 [GY92] 188 Y*O 16 27 03.00720 -24 26 14.6976           ~ 32 1
70 BKLT J162703-242007 Y*O 16 27 03.59088 -24 20 05.4456           M1.5 29 0
71 [GY92] 197 Y*O 16 27 05.24616 -24 36 29.7936           ~ 74 1
72 WL 17 Y*O 16 27 06.77616 -24 38 14.9964           ~ 113 0
73 WL 10 Or* 16 27 09.1062090672 -24 34 08.278196304           K9 79 0
74 Elia 2-29 Y*O 16 27 09.43032 -24 37 18.7716           ~ 296 1
75 WL 20 TT* 16 27 15.69840 -24 38 43.4364           M0 86 0
76 NAME WL 20E TT* 16 27 15.8951829912 -24 38 43.788560604           K7 78 0
77 2MASS J16271643-2431145 Y*O 16 27 16.438 -24 31 14.55           ~ 19 0
78 YLW 12A Y*O 16 27 17.57160 -24 28 56.2944           ~ 72 0
79 YLW 13B Y*O 16 27 21.46872 -24 41 43.0692           ~ 96 0
80 CRBR 2422.8-3423 Y*O 16 27 24.61320 -24 41 03.4080           ~ 101 1
81 YLW 15B Y*O 16 27 26.61768 -24 40 45.1524           ~ 33 0
82 YLW 16A Y*O 16 27 28.02744 -24 39 33.5052           K8 205 0
83 Elia 2-32 Y*O 16 27 28.44576 -24 27 21.0348           K6.5 121 1
84 Elia 2-33 Y*O 16 27 30.18024 -24 27 43.3656           M2 125 1
85 [GY92] 301 Y*O 16 27 37.24944 -24 42 38.0160           ~ 43 0
86 [GY92] 312 Y*O 16 27 38.94456 -24 40 20.6724           M2.5 52 0
87 DoAr 33 TT* 16 27 39.0123517344 -23 58 18.709495500   15.7   13.24 12.02 K4 100 0
88 ROX 27 TT* 16 27 39.4295731464 -24 39 15.527230272       15.76 14.03 M0+M4 137 0
89 [MAN98] F-MM7 mm 16 27 39.810 -24 43 12.25           ~ 4 0
90 YLW 45 Y*O 16 27 39.82824 -24 43 15.0672           ~ 120 0
91 BKLT J162741-244645 Y*O 16 27 41.61024 -24 46 44.7420           ~ 23 0
92 NAME Ophiuchus Molecular Cloud SFR 16 28 06 -24 32.5           ~ 3969 1
93 YLW 58 TT* 16 28 16.5129208176 -24 36 58.054939128   18.5   16.55 14.46 M4 119 0
94 [SSG2006] MMS126 Y*O 16 28 21.61 -24 36 23.4           ~ 38 0
95 BKLT J162854-244743 TT* 16 28 54.0781293792 -24 47 44.285434800   17.3   15.24 13.54 M2 57 0
96 BKLT J162858-244054 BD? 16 28 57.86880 -24 40 54.9156           ~ 18 0
97 2MASS J16302339-2454161 Or* 16 30 23.4030248496 -24 54 16.122323448   18.5       ~ 37 0
98 Haro 1-16 Or* 16 31 33.4634997336 -24 27 37.158728076   14.02 12.80     K3e 266 0
99 IRAS 16285-2355 Y*O 16 31 35.65752 -24 01 29.4708           ~ 178 0
100 2MASS J16313679-2404200 Y*O 16 31 36.80 -24 04 20.1           ~ 24 0
101 ISO-Oph 200 Y*O 16 31 43.7629847376 -24 55 24.548472336           ~ 29 0
102 ISO-Oph 203 Y*O 16 31 52.44696 -24 55 36.0804           ~ 20 0
103 WLY 2-67 Y*O 16 32 00.99624 -24 56 41.9640           ~ 67 0
104 NAME IRAS 16293-2422B Y*O 16 32 22.63 -24 28 31.8           ~ 352 0
105 NAME IRAS 16293-2422A Y*O 16 32 22.869 -24 28 36.11           ~ 207 0
106 2MASS J16335560-2442049 Y*O 16 33 55.6148566800 -24 42 05.002391016           K7 60 0
107 2MASS J16394544-2402039 TT* 16 39 45.4432704120 -24 02 03.885092160   16.0 12.7     K 46 0
108 2MASS J16395292-2419314 Y*? 16 39 52.927 -24 19 31.43           ~ 9 0
109 2MASS J16465826-0935197 Y*O 16 46 58.2599324664 -09 35 20.090942592   19.6 17.4     ~ 38 0
110 Hen 3-1258 Or* 16 48 45.6326070624 -14 16 35.849828856   14.94 13.34 12.84   K6 144 0
111 EM* AS 209 TT* 16 49 15.3034917000 -14 22 08.643317664   12.62 11.28     K4Ve 494 0
112 IRAS 16544-1604 Y*O 16 57 19.626 -16 09 23.30           ~ 53 1
113 HD 163296 Ae* 17 56 21.2881851168 -21 57 21.871819008 7.00 6.93 6.85 6.86 6.67 A3VaekA1mA1 1301 0
114 HD 169142 Ae* 18 24 29.7799891464 -29 46 49.327400568   8.42 8.16     F1VekA3mA3_lB? 535 0
115 NAME Serpens Cloud SFR 18 29 49 +01 14.8           ~ 1195 1
116 NAME Aql Region reg 18 31.1 -02 10           ~ 456 0
117 V* S CrA A Or* 19 01 08.5923211008 -36 57 19.736351172           ~ 43 0
118 V* S CrA B Y*O 19 01 08.6478545856 -36 57 20.880059148           ~ 32 0
119 [TS84] IRS 2 Y*O 19 01 41.569 -36 58 31.23           K2 97 0
120 CHLT 3 * 19 01 48.10 -36 57 22.7           K6V 37 0
121 CHLT 4 * 19 01 48.15 -36 57 22.3           ~ 17 0
122 2MASS J19014846-3657148 Y*O 19 01 48.461 -36 57 14.88           ~ 34 0
123 V* V710 CrA Or* 19 01 50.67792 -36 58 09.6132           K7: 131 0
124 NAME Corona Australis Cloud MoC 19 01 51 -36 58.9           ~ 554 0
125 2MASS J19015545-3657231 Y*O 19 01 55.460 -36 57 23.13           ~ 105 2
126 [FP2007] J190155.76-365727.7 Y*O 19 01 55.77 -36 57 27.5           ~ 14 0
127 CHLT 14 Y*O 19 01 56.41 -36 57 28.0           ~ 121 1
128 CHLT 15 Y*O 19 01 58.55 -36 57 08.7           ~ 28 0
129 [OTJ2023] R CrA IRAS 32B Y*O 19 02 58.642 -37 07 36.39           ~ 6 0
130 [OTJ2023] R CrA IRAS 32A Y*O 19 02 58.722 -37 07 37.39           ~ 8 0
131 V* VV CrA Or* 19 03 06.7410913704 -37 12 49.686912432   16.45 14.67 14.12 11.62 K7 133 0
132 NAME Gould Belt PoG ~ ~           ~ 956 1

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2025A&A...700A.235H and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu