2025A&A...703A.221T


Query : 2025A&A...703A.221T

2025A&A...703A.221T - Astronomy and Astrophysics, volume 703A221 (2025/11-1)

Evidence of a gap in the envelope mass fraction of sub-Saturns.

THOMAS L., NIELSEN L.D., ACUNA-AGUIRRE L. and CRIDLAND A.

Abstract (from CDS):

Under the core-accretion model, gas giants form via runaway accretion. This process starts when the mass of the accreted envelope becomes equal to the mass of the core. We modeled a population of warm sub-Saturns to search for imprints of their formation history in their internal structure. Using the GAS gianT modeL for Interiors (GASTLI), we calculated a grid of interior structure models on which we performed retrievals for our sample of 28 sub-Saturns to derive their envelope mass fractions (fenv). For each planet, we ran three different retrievals, assuming low (-2.0<log (Fe/H)<0.5), medium (0.5<log (Fe/H)<1.4), and high (1.4<log (Fe/H)<1.7) atmospheric metallicity. The distribution of fenv in our sample was then compared to outcomes and predictions of planet formation models. When our results are compared to the outcomes of a planetesimal accretion formation model, we find that we require a high atmospheric metallicity for intermediate-mass sub-Saturns to reproduce the simulated planet population. For higher planetary masses, a medium atmospheric metallicity provides the best agreement. Additionally, we find a bimodal distribution of fenv in our sample with a gap that is located at different values of fenv for different atmospheric metallicities. For the high atmospheric metallicity case, the gap in the fenv distribution is located between 0.5 and 0.7, which is consistent with assumptions of the core-accretion model in which runaway accretion starts when Menv ≈ Mcore(fenv is ∼ 0.5). We also find a bimodal distribution of the hydrogen and helium mass fraction (fH/He) with a gap at fH/He=0.3. The location of this gap is independent of the assumed atmospheric metallicity. Lastly, we compared the distributions of our sub-Saturns in the Neptunian savanna to a population of sub-Saturns in the Neptune desert and ridge. We find that the observed fenv distribution of savanna and ridge sub-Saturns is consistent with the planets coming from the same underlying population.

Abstract Copyright: © The Authors 2025

Journal keyword(s): planets and satellites: composition - planets and satellites: gaseous planets - planetary systems

Simbad objects: 67

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 67
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 TOI-4010 * 01 20 51.4586151266 +66 04 20.241816401   13.381 12.413 12.106   ~ 15 0
2 NGTS-11 * 01 34 05.1360759912 -14 25 09.152486616   13.304 12.411 12.297 11.48 ~ 23 0
3 TOI-2328b Pl 02 06 45.5618878104 -81 14 50.525404944           ~ 3 0
4 TOI-2328 * 02 06 45.5618878104 -81 14 50.525404944   13.37 12.33     ~ 6 0
5 TOI-5678b Pl 03 09 32.2118130648 -34 11 53.149633152           ~ 10 0
6 TOI-5678 PM* 03 09 32.2118130648 -34 11 53.149633152   12.03 11.44     G7V 10 0
7 CD-32 1952 * 04 43 59.4210951144 -31 54 23.401979532   11.20 10.51     ~ 14 0
8 TOI-216 PM* 04 55 55.2548838048 -63 15 36.313162056           ~ 58 0
9 TOI-2525b Pl 05 47 24.1880042543 -60 31 17.070197468           ~ 12 0
10 TOI-2525 * 05 47 24.1880042543 -60 31 17.070197468           K8V 16 0
11 BD+76 227 MS* 06 17 07.8623415000 +76 12 38.809391040   10.20 9.54     G5 25 0
12 TYC 2474-907-1 * 08 16 08.1193719576 +33 17 29.539830372   10.92 10.38     F8V 5 0
13 NAME TIC 139270665 b Pl 08 16 08.1193719576 +33 17 29.539830372           ~ 3 0
14 BD+19 2158b Pl 09 06 17.7565467792 +19 24 08.050560768           ~ 23 0
15 BD+19 2158 PM* 09 06 17.7565467792 +19 24 08.050560768   10.94 10.15     F8 35 0
16 HD 83342b Pl 09 38 13.3445304672 +23 32 48.925612536           ~ 7 0
17 HD 83342 PM* 09 38 13.3445304672 +23 32 48.925612536   8.34 7.86     F5 38 0
18 TOI-3071b Pl 11 33 06.9787339216 -56 30 12.273350645           ~ 5 0
19 BD+64 928 MS* 13 04 52.8851091096 +63 45 13.646778012   11.76 10.73     G 17 0
20 BD+64 928b Pl 13 04 52.8851091096 +63 45 13.646778012           ~ 7 0
21 BD+49 2411 * 15 37 43.6040512872 +48 57 19.462491252   11.08 10.26     ~ 12 0
22 TOI-2019.01 Pl? 15 37 43.6040512872 +48 57 19.462491252           ~ 6 0
23 TOI-1439.01 Pl? 16 07 03.3458173824 +67 52 39.824652972           ~ 6 0
24 TOI-1439 * 16 07 03.3458173824 +67 52 39.824652972   11.20 10.55     ~ 12 0
25 CD-24 12581 PM* 16 10 17.6976776832 -24 59 25.260709632   12.22 11.28     ~ 58 0
26 CD-24 12581c Pl 16 10 17.6976776832 -24 59 25.260709632           ~ 39 0
27 CD-24 12581b Pl 16 10 17.6976776832 -24 59 25.260709632           ~ 45 0
28 HD 148193b Pl 16 23 37.9700412072 +54 41 23.143746480           ~ 9 0
29 HD 148193 Em* 16 23 37.9700412072 +54 41 23.143746480   10.22 9.77     K0 18 0
30 BD+39 3325 PM* 18 07 44.4477668952 +39 04 26.923828368       8.893   K5V 34 0
31 BD+39 3325c Pl 18 07 44.4477668952 +39 04 26.923828368           ~ 9 0
32 TOI-4994b Pl 18 52 31.8027405163 -78 26 04.102997384           ~ 3 0
33 TOI-4994 * 18 52 31.8027405163 -78 26 04.102997384           ~ 2 0
34 Kepler-1656 Er* 18 57 53.3246033136 +39 54 42.531984144   12.016 11.252 11.096   G6V 81 0
35 Kepler-30d Pl 19 01 08.0746104528 +38 56 50.218268856           ~ 71 1
36 Kepler-30 Er* 19 01 08.0746104528 +38 56 50.218268856   16.50   15.767 14.55 ~ 180 1
37 Kepler-9 Er* 19 02 17.7544327200 +38 24 03.176851896     13.9 13.791   G2 223 1
38 Kepler-9b Pl 19 02 17.7544327200 +38 24 03.176851896           ~ 121 1
39 Kepler-9c Pl 19 02 17.7544327200 +38 24 03.176851896           ~ 109 1
40 Kepler-117b Pl 19 15 10.3301577216 +48 02 24.785162160           ~ 50 0
41 Kepler-117 Er* 19 15 10.3301577216 +48 02 24.785162160   15.056 14.476 14.266 13.69 F2 94 1
42 Kepler-103c Pl 19 15 56.2939334304 +40 03 52.285818168           ~ 43 0
43 Kepler-103 Er* 19 15 56.2939334304 +40 03 52.285818168   13.136 12.360 12.254   G5Ib 114 0
44 K2-139 * 19 16 15.9692401056 -17 54 38.409512868   12.43 11.65     K0V 29 0
45 Kepler-1662c Pl 19 17 21.9470227680 +46 59 17.635271604           ~ 31 0
46 Kepler-1662b Pl 19 17 21.9470227680 +46 59 17.635271604           ~ 32 0
47 Kepler-1662 Em* 19 17 21.9470227680 +46 59 17.635271604           K5 60 1
48 Kepler-86b Pl 19 19 03.2633425368 +51 57 45.409948812           ~ 45 1
49 Kepler-86 Ro* 19 19 03.2633425368 +51 57 45.409948812           F9 54 1
50 Kepler-1513 Ro* 19 19 09.9941837040 +39 17 06.928708560           K0V 48 0
51 Kepler-1513b Pl 19 19 09.9941837040 +39 17 06.928708560           ~ 23 0
52 Kepler-849b Pl 19 23 24.4340615640 +48 31 16.862220624           ~ 27 0
53 Kepler-849 Ro* 19 23 24.4340615640 +48 31 16.862220624           G0V 45 0
54 Kepler-280b Pl 19 25 33.7229065560 +42 10 50.052495036           ~ 24 0
55 K2-280b Pl 19 26 22.8813846576 -22 14 51.550486620           ~ 15 0
56 K2-280 * 19 26 22.8813846576 -22 14 51.550486620   13.27 12.54 12.41   ~ 24 0
57 Kepler-111c Pl 19 26 36.7607353488 +44 41 17.797093512           ~ 33 0
58 Kepler-111 Er* 19 26 36.7607353488 +44 41 17.797093512   14.341 13.619 13.459   F8V 70 0
59 Kepler-450 Er* 19 41 56.7727769064 +51 00 48.582305136   11.99 11.692 11.685   ~ 86 0
60 Kepler-450b Pl 19 41 56.7727769064 +51 00 48.582305136           ~ 39 0
61 Kepler-89 Ro* 19 49 19.9343204784 +41 53 28.006017936           ~ 175 1
62 Kepler-89e Pl 19 49 19.9343204784 +41 53 28.006017936           ~ 70 1
63 Kepler-539 Er* 19 56 29.3871979920 +41 52 00.317369676   13.150 12.519 12.342   G2V 82 0
64 HD 332231 MS* 20 26 57.9179575032 +33 44 40.026384168   9.11 8.56     F8 30 0
65 HD 332231b Pl 20 26 57.9179575032 +33 44 40.026384168           ~ 23 0
66 TOI-1386b Pl 22 18 00.8868538800 +54 19 08.400538236           ~ 8 0
67 TOI-1386 MS* 22 18 00.8868538800 +54 19 08.400538236   11.34 10.61     G5V 15 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2025A&A...703A.221T and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu