2025ApJ...978..115W


Query : 2025ApJ...978..115W

2025ApJ...978..115W - Astrophys. J., 978, 115 (2025/January-1)

Combining Direct Black Hole Mass Measurements and Spatially Resolved Stellar Kinematics to Calibrate the MBH-σ⋆ Relation of Active Galaxies.

WINKEL N., BENNERT V.N., REMIGIO R.P., TREU T., JAHNKE K., U V., BARTH A.J., MALKAN M., HUSEMANN B., DING X. and BIRRER S.

Abstract (from CDS):

The origin of the tight scaling relation between the mass of supermassive black holes (SMBHs; MBH) and their host-galaxy properties remains unclear. Active galactic nuclei (AGNs) probe phases of ongoing SMBH growth and offer the only opportunity to measure MBH beyond the local Universe. However, determining an AGN's host galaxy's stellar velocity dispersion, σ⋆, and its galaxy dynamical mass, Mdyn, is complicated by AGN contamination, aperture effects, and different host-galaxy morphologies. We select a sample of AGNs for which MBH has been independently determined to high accuracy by state-of-the-art techniques: dynamical modeling of the reverberation signal and spatially resolving the broad-line region with the Very Large Telescope Interferometer/GRAVITY. Using integral-field spectroscopic observations, we spatially map the host-galaxy stellar kinematics across the galaxy and bulge effective radii. We find that the dynamically hot component of galaxy disks correlates with MBH; however, the correlations are tightest for aperture-integrated σ⋆ measured across the bulge. Accounting for the different MBH distributions, we demonstrate-for the first time-that AGNs follow the same MBH-σ⋆ and MBH-Mbulge,dyn relations as quiescent galaxies. We confirm that the classical approach of determining the virial factor as a sample average, yielding $\mathrm{log}f=0.65\pm 0.18$, is consistent with the average f from individual measurements. The similarity between the underlying scaling relations of AGNs and quiescent galaxies implies that the current AGN phase is too short to have altered black hole masses on a population level. These results strengthen the local calibration of f for measuring single-epoch MBH in the distant Universe.

Abstract Copyright: © 2024. The Author(s). Published by the American Astronomical Society.

Journal keyword(s): AGN host galaxies - Active galaxies - Supermassive black holes - Scaling relations - Seyfert galaxies - Black hole physics - Galaxy evolution - Active galactic nuclei

Simbad objects: 44

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 44
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 Mrk 335 Sy1 00 06 19.5372339024 +20 12 10.617404076   14.19 13.85     ~ 1344 0
2 Mrk 1501 Bla 00 10 31.00590413 +10 58 29.5042981   15.96 15.40 12.22   ~ 763 1
3 LEDA 1790 Sy1 00 29 13.7012449608 +13 16 03.947778264   15.70 15.41     ~ 474 0
4 Z 535-12 Sy1 00 36 20.9390867880 +45 39 53.684333568   14.93 14.25     ~ 68 0
5 NGC 863 Sy2 02 14 33.5604714720 -00 46 00.181845336   14.48 13.81 17.9   ~ 770 0
6 MCG-02-07-024 Sy1 02 30 05.5225590096 -08 59 53.207139372   14.74 14.29 13.981 13.585 ~ 332 0
7 NGC 985 Sy1 02 34 37.882 -08 47 17.02   14.64 14.28 12.9   ~ 449 0
8 MCG+01-12-009 Bla 04 33 11.0956735296 +05 21 15.619461552   15.72 15.05 10.08   ~ 2099 2
9 Z 395-23 Sy1 05 16 11.4092471904 -00 08 59.157166920   14.30 13.92     ~ 953 1
10 NGC 2617 Sy2 08 35 38.7981089496 -04 05 17.901104280   13.6   12.63 13.2 ~ 226 0
11 [VV96] J091609.5-621929 Sy1 09 16 09.3662148312 -62 19 29.562130128   12.51 12.26 11.5   ~ 163 0
12 Z 121-75 Sy1 09 23 43.0005086832 +22 54 32.576001696   16.23 15.82     ~ 165 0
13 Mrk 110 Sy1 09 25 12.8479065576 +52 17 10.386311208   16.82 16.41     ~ 681 1
14 Z 7-49 Sy1 09 52 19.168 -01 36 44.10   14.99 14.39 11.2   ~ 348 1
15 Z 313-11 Sy1 10 19 12.5653238136 +63 58 02.626090176   16.32 16.00     ~ 166 0
16 NGC 3227 Sy1 10 23 30.5765149296 +19 51 54.282206700   12.61 11.79     ~ 1807 2
17 Mrk 142 Sy1 10 25 31.2786898344 +51 40 34.867889004   16.33 16.12     ~ 330 0
18 Z 291-51 Sy1 11 18 57.7039218648 +58 03 23.629382172   17.12 16.69     ~ 119 0
19 MCG+09-19-073 Sy1 11 25 36.1539761184 +54 22 57.113791824   17.06 16.47     ~ 311 0
20 NGC 3783 Sy1 11 39 01.7096819040 -37 44 19.009642992   12.46 13.43 11.33 12.1 ~ 1765 1
21 Mrk 1310 Sy1 12 01 14.3530384560 -03 40 41.015051940   16.31 15.89 14.780   ~ 218 0
22 PB 3894 Sy1 12 14 17.6738687784 +14 03 13.182723144   14.46 14.19     ~ 873 0
23 Mrk 50 Sy1 12 23 24.1362367968 +02 40 44.449405212   17.25 16.63     ~ 263 1
24 3C 273 BLL 12 29 06.6998257176 +02 03 08.597629980   13.05 14.830 14.11   ~ 6022 1
25 NGC 4593 Sy1 12 39 39.4435107024 -05 20 39.034988448   13.95 13.15     ~ 1179 0
26 LEDA 45913 Sy1 13 13 05.7810527568 -11 07 42.369955428   15.48 15.15 13.4   ~ 159 0
27 LEDA 84044 Sy1 13 41 12.8835794640 -14 38 40.247801448   15.02 14.63 11.5   ~ 98 0
28 IC 4329A Sy1 13 49 19.2601801224 -30 18 34.213815504   13.81 13.66 12.18 12.35 ~ 876 1
29 Z 336-28 Sy1 13 53 03.4348964112 +69 18 29.410910460   15.15 14.46     ~ 812 1
30 NGC 5548 Sy1 14 17 59.5400291832 +25 08 12.603122268   14.35 13.73     ~ 2895 0
31 Mrk 1383 Sy1 14 29 06.5720038632 +01 17 06.155007252   15.21 14.87     ~ 494 0
32 Mrk 841 Sy1 15 04 01.1935384104 +10 26 15.780409692   14.50 14.27     ~ 701 0
33 Z 48-115 Sy1 15 05 56.5521472536 +03 42 26.339214780   15.80 15.50     ~ 159 0
34 NGC 5940 Sy1 15 31 18.0815283384 +07 27 27.842445432   15.56 14.90     ~ 214 0
35 Mrk 877 Sy1 16 20 11.2799789400 +17 24 27.515242152   15.79 15.39     ~ 286 0
36 2MASX J18530389+2750275 Sy1 18 53 03.8648360160 +27 50 27.840599916     12.50     ~ 31 1
37 Z 229-15 Sy1 19 05 25.9385931648 +42 27 39.759455520   15.4       ~ 146 0
38 NGC 6814 Sy1 19 42 40.5862186152 -10 19 25.108718844   15.33 14.21 11.7 11.3 ~ 866 0
39 LEDA 3096594 Sy1 20 44 04.2555266496 +28 33 09.404396928           ~ 52 1
40 Mrk 509 Sy1 20 44 09.7504483224 -10 43 24.727155528   13.35 13.12 10.7   ~ 1370 0
41 Mrk 1513 Sy1 21 32 27.8162556672 +10 08 19.252365396   14.92 14.64     ~ 651 0
42 QSO B2209+184 BLL 22 11 53.8888927344 +18 41 49.861248288   16.09 15.44 11.96   ~ 187 2
43 LEDA 3096710 Sy1 22 56 36.4606611288 +05 25 17.097921120   16.2 16.2     ~ 44 0
44 NGC 7469 Sy1 23 03 15.6 +08 52 26 12.60 13.00 12.34     ~ 2253 3

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2025ApJ...978..115W and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu