2025ApJ...992...75S


Query : 2025ApJ...992...75S

2025ApJ...992...75S - Astrophys. J., 992, 75 (2025/October-2)

Lithium Abundances of Main-sequence Stars in the Old Open Cluster NGC 188: Probes of Stellar Evolution beyond the Solar Age.

SUN Q., DELIYANNIS C.P., TWAROG B.A. and ANTHONY-TWAROG B.J.

Abstract (from CDS):

We present lithium abundances for 119 main-sequence stars in the old open cluster NGC 188 (age = 6.3 Gyr), using high-resolution, high signal-to-noise ratio spectra from WIYN/Hydra. We observe the stars over multiple nights and measure radial velocities for each night, which we combine with Gaia proper motions to identify multiplicity and cluster membership. We identify 95 single members, 14 binary members, 9 members with uncertain multiplicity, and 1 single likely member. We determine effective temperatures using empirical color-temperature relations, surface gravities from isochrones, and microturbulence from empirical relations for main-sequence stars. Our sample includes G dwarfs with temperatures between 6000 and 5300 K, which expands significantly on earlier observations. We find that lithium abundances in NGC 188 are lower than predictions from standard stellar evolution theory. As expected, stars in NGC 188 are more lithium-depleted than those in the younger Hyades and Praesepe clusters (650 Myr). However, their abundances are higher, or at least comparable, to those in the slightly younger cluster M67 (4 Gyr), challenging the idea that older stars have lower lithium than younger ones. Lithium depletion may depend on factors beyond age and mass, such as metallicity.

Abstract Copyright: © 2025. The Author(s). Published by the American Astronomical Society.

Journal keyword(s): Spectroscopy - Observational astronomy - Chemical abundances - Stellar evolution

Status at CDS : Large table(s) will be appraised for possible ingestion in VizieR.

Simbad objects: 127

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 127
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 Cl* NGC 188 DGV 1134 * 00 28 33.2732443584 +85 11 56.375299536   15.836 15.166     ~ 11 0
2 Cl* NGC 188 PKM 3176 * 00 34 00.3126121824 +85 11 15.241259004   17.038 16.299     ~ 3 0
3 Cl* NGC 188 DGV 1581 * 00 35 33.4630714968 +85 21 12.732427152   15.811 15.162     ~ 10 0
4 Cl* NGC 188 PKM 3843 * 00 37 27.2136832896 +85 10 28.080150888 17.900 17.595 16.769 16.308 15.847 ~ 8 0
5 Cl* NGC 188 PKM 3852 * 00 37 33.6947979816 +85 09 39.064821372 17.803 17.403 16.640 16.170 15.768 ~ 8 0
6 Cl* NGC 188 DGV 232 * 00 37 58.7710539360 +85 01 33.376597212   16.599 15.937     ~ 11 0
7 Cl* NGC 188 PKM 3699 * 00 38 12.0343193568 +85 22 55.128422496 17.750 17.410 16.621 16.177 15.752 ~ 8 0
8 Cl* NGC 188 DGV 980 * 00 38 23.0718674256 +85 14 19.257963180 16.808 16.615 15.906 15.486 15.106 ~ 11 0
9 Cl* NGC 188 DGV 861 SB* 00 38 32.2561834416 +85 08 08.751480972 16.098 15.948 15.300 14.887 14.527 ~ 13 0
10 Cl* NGC 188 PKM 3827 * 00 39 12.5128917576 +85 11 50.924978124 17.948 17.542 16.710 16.240 15.790 ~ 8 0
11 Cl* NGC 188 PKM 3939 * 00 39 39.8137542192 +85 22 04.830421656 17.610 17.302 16.523 16.075 15.656 ~ 8 0
12 NGC 188 3157 * 00 40 47.7528489648 +85 14 32.161784424 16.314 16.127 15.464 15.062 14.688 ~ 12 0
13 NGC 188 3158 * 00 40 57.5458242936 +85 14 37.353592896 16.614 16.400 15.711 15.289 14.891 ~ 11 0
14 NGC 188 3001 SB* 00 41 15.8284598496 +85 12 32.326525872 16.384 16.21 15.52 15.109 14.731 ~ 17 0
15 Cl* NGC 188 DGV 834 * 00 41 23.4181352712 +85 09 55.124065044 16.645 16.463 15.759 15.315 14.927 ~ 12 0
16 Cl* NGC 188 SMV 5294 * 00 41 26.3784400848 +85 21 11.643215076 18.287 17.819 16.976 16.483 16.045 ~ 8 0
17 NGC 188 3155 V* 00 41 50.6463664248 +85 15 46.774034280 17.103 16.84 16.10 15.707 15.310 ~ 12 0
18 NGC 188 3005 * 00 42 08.3459553408 +85 12 00.951821244 16.150 15.939 15.273 14.868 14.496 ~ 13 0
19 Cl* NGC 188 PKM 4170 * 00 42 11.4410933880 +85 25 21.895046508   17.747 16.907 16.424 15.977 ~ 5 0
20 NGC 188 3148 * 00 42 25.0097613624 +85 17 37.254757704 16.657 16.452 15.775 15.352 14.999 ~ 13 0
21 NGC 188 3142 * 00 42 30.3312263304 +85 18 38.963018772 16.667 16.480 15.805 15.380 15.017 ~ 13 0
22 NGC 188 3008 * 00 42 48.6906103800 +85 11 46.871261664 16.348 16.172 15.504 15.104 14.738 ~ 12 0
23 Cl* NGC 188 PKM 8282 * 00 42 49.2900952320 +85 01 42.477438900   17.517 16.719     ~ 8 0
24 NGC 188 2027 * 00 42 53.3466424440 +85 13 38.898982884 16.128 15.98 15.30 14.850 14.482 G3Vp 14 0
25 NGC 188 3141 * 00 42 58.6343672832 +85 19 06.847633776 16.658 16.472 15.813 15.414 15.056 ~ 13 0
26 NGC 188 2023 * 00 43 04.9909494528 +85 11 24.261650556 17.062 16.816 16.092 15.665 15.273 ~ 11 0
27 NGC 188 2020 SB* 00 43 42.0160257384 +85 10 43.274084016 16.017 15.838 15.191 14.771 14.412 ~ 13 0
28 Cl* NGC 188 PKM 8249 * 00 43 45.9737417376 +85 04 24.673904148 17.786 17.379 16.599 16.133 15.710 ~ 7 0
29 NGC 188 2017 * 00 43 57.9881892072 +85 11 29.715882396 16.805 16.587 15.883 15.466 15.091 ~ 14 0
30 NGC 188 2043 * 00 43 58.2517715616 +85 14 55.129198632 16.776 16.60 15.87 15.425 15.039 ~ 15 0
31 NGC 188 3133 * 00 44 01.4408412000 +85 19 56.577507132 16.890 16.659 15.975 15.564 15.195 ~ 11 0
32 NGC 188 2041 * 00 44 01.9085798472 +85 14 22.789039128 16.614 16.407 15.718 15.302 14.919 ~ 14 0
33 Cl* NGC 188 DGV 1481 * 00 44 11.1055034904 +85 27 47.053003824   15.862 15.230     ~ 12 0
34 NGC 188 2048 * 00 44 12.9540007896 +85 16 27.711599124 16.638 16.456 15.781 15.373 14.996 ~ 14 0
35 Cl* NGC 188 DGV 1466 * 00 44 15.6896841192 +85 24 02.384580420 16.888 16.719 16.045 15.656 15.275 ~ 11 0
36 NGC 188 2054 * 00 44 23.2139308056 +85 17 20.967066312 16.216 16.028 15.377 14.995 14.620 ~ 15 0
37 NGC 188 3020 * 00 44 26.7810399120 +85 09 20.923661160 16.274 16.104 15.446 15.048 14.678 ~ 13 0
38 NGC 188 2069 * 00 44 44.7236344488 +85 18 54.109821708 15.967 15.790 15.148 14.755 14.389 ~ 22 0
39 V* V769 Cep BY* 00 44 52.1752652280 +85 15 54.480423816 16.723 16.484 15.772 15.328 14.905 ~ 17 0
40 NGC 188 2055 * 00 44 58.0912807536 +85 16 40.577737656 16.236 16.03 15.38 14.981 14.606 ~ 15 0
41 NGC 188 3022 * 00 45 01.6522773000 +85 09 01.704918996 16.149 15.97 15.28 14.882 14.497 ~ 15 0
42 NGC 188 2002 * 00 45 17.3270065248 +85 12 21.918665160 16.167 15.995 15.333 14.946 14.565 G1Vp 14 0
43 NGC 188 3124 * 00 45 30.3807836232 +85 22 23.440156896 16.548 16.352 15.681 15.300 14.916 ~ 13 0
44 Cl* NGC 188 DGV 543 * 00 45 33.3754055400 +85 05 48.632441244 16.005 15.874 15.232 14.848 14.472 ~ 13 0
45 Cl* NGC 188 DGV 581 * 00 45 47.7896647464 +85 11 05.918259084 16.240 16.090 15.421 15.020 14.652 ~ 11 0
46 NGC 188 1115 * 00 45 52.5224595552 +85 12 24.298944948 16.635 16.436 15.756 15.347 14.973 ~ 14 0
47 NGC 188 3028 * 00 45 59.7708120648 +85 07 08.774766408 16.987 16.801 16.085 15.662 15.267 ~ 12 0
48 NGC 188 2078 * 00 46 01.7582212752 +85 19 37.200486828 16.618 16.438 15.765 15.367 14.989 ~ 14 0
49 Cl* NGC 188 DGV 138 * 00 46 02.8982363928 +85 03 28.981350540   16.234 15.587     ~ 11 0
50 NGC 188 3029 * 00 46 16.8904640376 +85 06 43.829269128 16.248 16.06 15.38 14.980 14.597 ~ 14 0
51 NGC 188 1039 * 00 46 28.5032036016 +85 15 58.113272412 16.968 16.766 16.076 15.661 15.288 ~ 13 0
52 NGC 188 1108 * 00 46 36.5056550112 +85 13 03.572320008 16.119 15.87 15.15 14.726 14.358 ~ 11 0
53 Cl* NGC 188 PKM 8625 * 00 46 41.7050258496 +84 58 06.846888936   16.912 16.222     ~ 10 0
54 NGC 188 1040 SB* 00 46 43.2226218480 +85 16 05.783009304 16.176 15.945 15.274 14.867 14.501 ~ 17 0
55 NGC 188 1104 * 00 47 00.6389306040 +85 13 50.406463524 16.266 16.08 15.39 15.051 14.695 ~ 15 0
56 NGC 188 1034 * 00 47 00.7477532328 +85 16 41.641424976 16.839 16.56 15.83 15.459 15.081 ~ 15 0
57 NGC 188 1103 * 00 47 03.5872024200 +85 13 36.990406308 15.948 15.76 15.14 14.774 14.423 ~ 14 0
58 NGC 188 1081 SB* 00 47 06.2327509032 +85 14 30.969158676 16.819 16.56 15.80 15.474 15.078 ~ 18 0
59 NGC 188 OpC 00 47 14.8 +85 14 42           ~ 990 0
60 NGC 188 2174 * 00 47 16.6093681752 +85 10 27.000855120 16.603 16.404 15.702 15.267 14.889 ~ 12 0
61 NGC 188 3033 * 00 47 18.3041336712 +85 08 35.962556856 16.375 16.19 15.53 15.126 14.746 ~ 14 0
62 NGC 188 1101 * 00 47 19.6084923312 +85 13 19.641986004 15.865 15.68 15.00 14.705 14.351 ~ 24 0
63 NGC 188 1100 * 00 47 24.0130314552 +85 12 16.654861332 16.151 15.93 15.23 14.795 14.422 ~ 15 0
64 NGC 188 2173 * 00 47 25.9926975888 +85 09 42.337191636 16.423 16.285 15.627 15.213 14.848 ~ 13 0
65 NGC 188 2089 * 00 47 28.2395645856 +85 19 41.031331392 16.392 16.235 15.570 15.182 14.791 ~ 14 0
66 NGC 188 3116 * 00 47 30.7436635920 +85 21 33.067340568 16.058 15.913 15.254 14.868 14.468 ~ 13 0
67 Cl* NGC 188 PKM 4789 * 00 47 35.2699328592 +85 27 13.249230876   17.796 16.945     ~ 8 0
68 NGC 188 2172 * 00 47 58.4336951352 +85 09 26.970567768 17.457 17.186 16.413 15.948 15.544 ~ 12 0
69 NGC 188 2092 * 00 48 02.1732539544 +85 19 24.660466932 17.565 17.262 16.489 16.041 15.604 ~ 12 0
70 Cl* NGC 188 SMV 8288 * 00 48 03.8567180112 +85 23 05.176714668 17.420 17.151 16.402 15.979 15.557 ~ 10 0
71 NGC 188 1030 SB* 00 48 16.5255547104 +85 16 46.169508396 16.141 15.975 15.282 14.863 14.453 ~ 16 0
72 NGC 188 2098 * 00 48 22.1917575792 +85 17 52.580280552 16.897 16.677 15.976 15.572 15.154 ~ 13 0
73 NGC 188 1095 * 00 48 22.4260631664 +85 13 02.400801852 16.999 16.77 16.05 15.626 15.259 ~ 15 0
74 NGC 188 2164 * 00 48 26.4285522144 +85 10 35.352661872 17.210 17.017 16.280 15.854 15.452 ~ 12 0
75 NGC 188 2171 * 00 48 31.1664535776 +85 09 39.970744704 16.719 16.518 15.825 15.396 15.011 ~ 13 0
76 NGC 188 3112 * 00 48 35.6772968568 +85 21 18.734874048 16.028 15.866 15.201 14.789 14.417 ~ 12 0
77 Cl* NGC 188 DGV 510 * 00 48 42.0854800680 +85 05 30.344134668 16.468 16.312 15.643 15.248 14.841 ~ 12 0
78 NGC 188 2097 * 00 48 44.7531616224 +85 17 42.687866004 16.321 16.166 15.508 15.133 14.746 ~ 14 0
79 V* V776 Cep BY* 00 48 54.9962839752 +85 17 12.713680932 17.940 17.516 16.723 16.266 15.834 ~ 12 0
80 NGC 188 2109 * 00 48 58.5695239128 +85 15 59.184562608 17.387 17.081 16.333 15.893 15.494 ~ 11 0
81 NGC 188 2169 * 00 49 02.9194058088 +85 10 16.535225676 16.567 16.400 15.727 15.317 14.942 ~ 14 0
82 NGC 188 2108 * 00 49 05.5337359608 +85 16 14.253430368 15.943 15.779 15.134 14.726 14.374 ~ 16 0
83 NGC 188 2144 * 00 49 08.7012535992 +85 13 26.384105532 17.379 17.080 16.333 15.884 15.510 ~ 13 0
84 NGC 188 2120 * 00 49 11.2071751200 +85 15 11.964800268 17.667 17.332 16.567 16.104 15.706 ~ 9 0
85 NGC 188 2121 * 00 49 25.3436835048 +85 14 53.897420328 17.217 16.97 16.26 15.790 15.411 ~ 13 0
86 Cl* NGC 188 PKM 5491 * 00 49 40.9088782968 +85 09 43.482278376 18.302 17.843 16.995 16.504 16.040 ~ 9 0
87 NGC 188 2130 * 00 49 44.8227239856 +85 13 58.027089000 17.747 17.476 16.681 16.216 15.835 ~ 7 0
88 Cl* NGC 188 DGV 110 * 00 49 45.1502113176 +84 59 13.910959500   17.023 16.302     ~ 10 0
89 NGC 188 2145 * 00 49 53.3646128832 +85 13 03.696757284 16.476 16.281 15.613 15.212 14.844 ~ 14 0
90 NGC 188 2125 * 00 49 58.5484492608 +85 14 45.657744612 16.733 16.566 15.874 15.463 15.098 ~ 14 0
91 NGC 188 2112 * 00 50 18.3351641952 +85 16 08.399156484 17.091 16.85 16.12 15.696 15.310 ~ 14 0
92 NGC 188 2131 SB* 00 50 25.2692003784 +85 14 05.296175664 17.389 17.11 16.35 15.875 15.476 ~ 14 0
93 NGC 188 2115 * 00 50 46.3706150688 +85 16 33.730536288 16.797 16.58 15.85 15.449 15.062 ~ 14 0
94 NGC 188 3097 * 00 51 00.2892112776 +85 19 35.211505296 17.134 16.901 16.172 15.732 15.362 ~ 12 0
95 NGC 188 2135 * 00 51 04.6079992344 +85 13 48.024623640 18.101 17.657 16.825 16.327 15.909 ~ 9 0
96 Cl* NGC 188 PKM 1633 * 00 51 39.6012125640 +85 29 22.613944020   16.970 16.214     ~ 10 0
97 NGC 188 3060 * 00 51 41.6639691912 +85 12 33.813562068 17.160 16.932 16.177 15.744 15.352 ~ 12 0
98 Cl* NGC 188 SMV 10108 SB* 00 51 55.1851412688 +85 07 52.073613696 16.762 16.544 15.853 15.415 15.034 ~ 15 0
99 NGC 188 3054 * 00 52 03.2197959600 +85 11 47.329860012 16.501 16.349 15.653 15.250 14.875 ~ 14 0
100 NGC 188 3071 * 00 52 39.6076904856 +85 14 21.653496996 17.140 16.914 16.172 15.740 15.346 ~ 12 0
101 NGC 188 3065 * 00 52 49.3206265896 +85 13 28.252527456 16.400 16.210 15.528 15.117 14.751 ~ 14 0
102 NGC 188 3079 * 00 53 18.0457684584 +85 15 35.252873028 17.324 17.033 16.279 15.825 15.438 ~ 11 0
103 Cl* NGC 188 SMV 10590 SB* 00 53 22.2840695568 +85 20 27.040766748 16.455 16.279 15.597 15.164 14.789 ~ 13 0
104 Cl* NGC 188 PKM 9130 * 00 53 37.8481669752 +85 04 21.416986416 18.126 17.649 16.829 16.342 15.933 ~ 7 0
105 Cl* NGC 188 SMV 10799 * 00 53 38.9476565568 +85 07 03.612330552 16.624 16.453 15.773 15.357 14.983 ~ 12 0
106 Cl* NGC 188 DGV 1245 * 00 53 54.9521552280 +85 17 24.447390936 16.333 16.176 15.511 15.113 14.743 ~ 12 0
107 Cl* NGC 188 PKM 6158 * 00 54 00.4525504752 +85 14 27.180504276 17.471 17.203 16.428 15.974 15.563 ~ 10 0
108 Cl* NGC 188 PKM 6171 SB* 00 54 50.4335700768 +85 12 51.965236260 17.315 17.052 16.309 15.834 15.462 ~ 12 0
109 Cl* NGC 188 SMV 11173 * 00 54 56.6995111512 +85 13 29.432137980 16.241 16.083 15.409 15.002 14.656 ~ 12 0
110 Cl* NGC 188 SMV 11341 * 00 55 39.9009990720 +85 16 58.991219148 16.628 16.419 15.739 15.335 14.976 ~ 12 0
111 Cl* NGC 188 DGV 90 * 00 55 54.7936860600 +85 01 52.558231188   17.042 16.285     ~ 10 0
112 Cl* NGC 188 SMV 11410 * 00 56 19.7913360912 +85 25 36.951615408   15.840 15.126     ~ 11 0
113 Cl* NGC 188 PKM 9271 * 00 57 00.1748466072 +85 00 47.185681500   17.705 16.875     ~ 7 0
114 Cl* NGC 188 PKM 6330 * 00 57 18.7423325352 +85 13 45.243349428   17.360 16.560     ~ 8 0
115 Cl* NGC 188 PKM 6518 * 00 58 04.0251442224 +85 09 04.300491924   16.968 16.209     ~ 9 0
116 Cl* NGC 188 PKM 6478 * 00 59 22.0103101608 +85 14 16.225951560   17.231 16.456     ~ 10 0
117 Cl* NGC 188 PKM 6488 * 00 59 27.0325206312 +85 12 55.164249648   17.518 16.701     ~ 7 0
118 Cl* NGC 188 SMV 12074 * 01 00 10.3009829208 +85 34 21.866612808   16.095 15.412     ~ 11 0
119 Cl* NGC 188 SMV 13020 * 01 04 46.7156528136 +85 22 04.968412500   15.833 15.165     ~ 11 0
120 Cl* NGC 188 SMV 13259 * 01 05 30.2097739608 +85 12 25.508079648   15.936 15.261     ~ 11 0
121 NGC 752 OpC 01 56 53.7 +37 45 06           ~ 712 0
122 Cl Melotte 22 OpC 03 46 38.0 +24 10 41           ~ 3679 0
123 Cl Melotte 25 OpC 04 30 27.4 +16 46 43           ~ 3309 0
124 NGC 2168 OpC 06 09 07.5 +24 20 15           ~ 604 0
125 NGC 2632 OpC 08 39 58.4 +19 36 33           ~ 1733 0
126 NGC 2682 OpC 08 51 23.5 +11 48 54           ~ 2528 0
127 NGC 6819 OpC 19 41 18.3 +40 11 19   8.21 7.3     ~ 719 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2025ApJ...992...75S and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu