2025ApJ...994...49F


Query : 2025ApJ...994...49F

2025ApJ...994...49F - Astrophys. J., 994, 49 (2025/November-3)

Reconciling the Tension between Light-curve Modeling of Type II Supernovae and Neutrino-driven Core-collapse Supernovae Models with Late-phase Spectroscopy.

FANG Q., NAGAKURA H. and MORIYA T.J.

Abstract (from CDS):

Type II supernovae (SNe II) are the most frequently observed outcome of core-collapse explosions and provide a valuable window into the physical mechanisms governing the deaths of massive stars. However, estimates of explosion properties based on optical light-curve modeling often show tension with the predictions of modern neutrino-driven explosion models. In particular, when based on light curves from the explosions of red supergiants (RSGs) tied to specific stellar wind models, many SNe II are found to originate from low-mass progenitors yet exhibit unusually high explosion energies (EK), far exceeding theoretical predictions. In this study, we incorporate late-phase (nebular) spectroscopy to estimate the helium core mass of the progenitor (${M}_{{\rm{He}}\,{\rm{core}}}$), which serves as an additional constraint to break degeneracies in light-curve modeling. This approach is applied to a sample of 32 well-observed SNe II, using a light-curve model grid constructed from RSGs with arbitrarily stripped hydrogen-rich envelopes, rather than assuming a fixed wind model. Examining the resulting correlations among the physical parameters, we find that the tension between the observed ${M}_{{\rm{He}}\,{\rm{core}}}$-EK and EK-MNi relations and those predicted by neutrino-driven explosion models has significantly lessened by incorporating nebular spectroscopy in light-curve modeling. This study highlights the crucial role of nebular spectroscopy in interpreting SNe II observations and provides support to the neutrino-driven explosion mechanism as the dominant engine powering these events.

Abstract Copyright: © 2025. The Author(s). Published by the American Astronomical Society.

Journal keyword(s): Core-collapse supernovae - Type II supernovae - Explosive nucleosynthesis

Simbad objects: 33

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 33
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 SN 2014cx SN* 00 59 47.83 -07 34 18.6           SNIIP 52 1
2 SN 2003gd SN* 01 36 42.65 +15 44 19.9     13.2     SNIIP 267 2
3 SN 2013ej SN* 01 36 48.16 +15 45 31.0           SNIIP 248 0
4 SN 2012ec SN* 02 45 59.89 -07 34 25.0         22.32 SNIIP 92 3
5 SN 2003B SN* 02 46 13.78 -30 13 45.1     15.0     SNIIP 47 2
6 SN 2009ib SN* 04 17 40.09 -62 46 40.3           SNIIP 70 1
7 SN 1999em SN* 04 41 27.04 -02 51 45.2   13.79 13.7     SNIIP 727 1
8 2MASS J07371703+6535579 HXB 07 37 17.0432126424 +65 35 57.826001220           SNIIP 317 1
9 SN 2018hwm SN* 08 21 28.2 +03 09 52           SNII 18 0
10 SN 2012A SN* 10 25 07.39 +17 09 14.6           SNIIP 135 0
11 SN 2021gmj SN* 10 38 47.270 +53 30 30.31           SNII 17 0
12 SN 2012aw SN* 10 43 53.735 +11 40 17.63       15   SNIIP 252 1
13 SN 2014G SN* 10 54 34.13 +54 17 56.9           SNIIL 95 1
14 SN 2024ggi SN* 11 18 22.087 -32 50 15.27           SNII 50 0
15 SN 2013am SN* 11 18 56.95 +13 03 49.4           SNII 52 1
16 SN 2005ay SN* 11 52 48.07 +44 06 18.4   15.3       SNIIP 74 1
17 SN 2007aa SN* 12 00 27.69 -01 04 51.6 16.9 16.4 5.8     SNIIP 78 1
18 SN 1991G SN* 12 05 28.85 +50 32 11.7   15.7       SNIIP 54 1
19 SN 2009dd SN* 12 05 34.10 +50 32 18.6           SNII 46 1
20 SN 2020jfo SN* 12 21 50.480 +04 28 54.05           SNII 48 0
21 SN 2009N SN* 12 31 09.46 -08 02 56.3           SNIIP 111 1
22 SN 2016X SN* 12 55 15.50 +00 05 59.7           SNIIb 61 0
23 SN 2018is SN? 13 16 57.350 -16 37 04.43           ~ 8 0
24 SN 2005cs SN* 13 29 53.37 +47 10 28.2   14.5       SNIIP 450 1
25 SN 2023ixf SN* 14 03 38.562 +54 18 41.94           SNII 209 0
26 SN 2018gj SN* 16 32 02.31 +78 12 40.9           SNII 21 0
27 SN 2004A SN* 16 43 01.90 +36 50 12.5     15.7     SNIIP 90 1
28 SN 2013by SN* 16 59 02.43 -60 11 41.8           SNII 83 1
29 SN 2017eaw SN* 20 34 44.238 +60 11 36.00           SNIIP 180 0
30 SN 2004et SN* 20 35 25.33 +60 07 17.7   12.88       SNIIP 547 1
31 SN 2018cuf SN* 21 16 11.580 -64 28 57.26           SNII 17 0
32 SN 2013fs SN* 23 19 44.70 +10 11 05.0           SNIIP 159 1
33 SN 2008bk SN* 23 57 50.42 -32 33 21.5           SNIIP 167 2

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2025ApJ...994...49F and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu