2025MNRAS.540.3247S


Query : 2025MNRAS.540.3247S

2025MNRAS.540.3247S - Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 540, 3247-3262 (2025/July-2)

All known Type Ia supernovae models fail to reproduce the observed bolometric luminosity-width correlation.

SHARON A., KUSHNIR D. and WYGODA N.

Abstract (from CDS):

Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) are widely believed to arise from thermonuclear explosions of white dwarfs (WDs). However, ongoing debate surrounds their progenitor systems and the mechanisms triggering these explosions. Recently, Sharon & Kushnir showed that existing models do not reproduce the observed positive correlation between the $\gamma$-ray escape time, $t_0$, and the synthesized $^{56}$Ni mass, $M_\mathrm{Ni56}$. Their analysis, while avoiding complex radiation transfer (RT) calculations, did not account for the viewing-angle dependence of the derived $t_0$ and $M_\mathrm{Ni56}$ in multidimensional (multi-D) models during pre-nebular phases, where most observations performed. Here, we aim to identify an observational width-luminosity relation, similar to the $t_0$-$M_\mathrm{Ni56}$ relation to constrain multi-D models during pre-nebular phases while minimizing RT calculation uncertainties. We show that the bolometric luminosity at $t\le 30$ d since explosion can be accurately computed without non-thermal ionization considerations, which are computationally expensive and uncertain. We find that the ratio of the bolometric luminosity at 30 d since explosion to the peak luminosity, $L_{30}/Lp$, correlates strongly with $t_0$. Using a sample of well-observed SNe Ia, we show that this parameter tightly correlates with the peak luminosity, $L_\mathrm{ p}$. We compare the observed $L_{30}/Lp$-$L_\mathrm{ p}$ distribution with models from the literature, including non-spherical models consisting of head-on WD collisions and off-centred ignitions of sub-Chandrasekhar mass WDs. We find that all known SNe Ia models fail to reproduce the observed bolometric luminosity-width correlation.

Abstract Copyright: © 2025 The Author(s). Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of Royal Astronomical Society.

Journal keyword(s): methods: data analysis - supernovae: general

Status at CDS : Large table(s) will be appraised for possible ingestion in VizieR.

Simbad objects: 48

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 48
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 SN 2008hj SN* 00 04 01.913 -11 10 08.35           SNIa 45 1
2 SN 2006et SN* 00 42 45.82 -23 33 30.4     16.1     SNIa 82 1
3 SN 2005hc SN* 01 56 47.976 -00 12 48.62           SNIa 99 1
4 SN 2005A SN* 02 30 43.25 -02 56 19.8     17.1     SNIa 60 1
5 SN 2006mr SN* 03 22 42.84 -37 12 28.5     15.6     SNIap 78 1
6 SN 2008gp SN* 03 23 00.73 +01 21 42.8           SNIa 51 1
7 SN 2012fr SN* 03 33 35.99 -36 07 37.7           SNIa-norm 178 1
8 SN 2005ke SN* 03 35 04.35 -24 56 38.8     17.2     SNIap 162 1
9 SN 2007on SN* 03 38 50.90 -35 34 30.0       14.9   SNIa 153 1
10 SN 2006kf SN* 03 41 50.48 +08 09 25.0     17.4     SNIa 78 1
11 SN 2009D SN* 03 54 22.83 -19 10 54.2           SNIa-norm 43 1
12 SN 2009ab SN* 04 16 36.39 +02 45 51.0           SNIa 33 1
13 SN 2021aefx SN* 04 19 53.380 -54 56 53.24           SNIa 48 0
14 SN 2009F SN* 04 59 23.56 -11 07 50.1           SNIap 41 1
15 SN 2009ad SN* 05 03 33.38 +06 39 35.7           SNIa 49 1
16 SN 2005el SN* 05 11 48.76 +05 11 39.0     18.7     SNIa 118 1
17 SN 2008fp SN* 07 16 32.60 -29 19 31.7           SNIa 79 1
18 SN 2015F SN* 07 36 15.76 -69 30 23.0           SNIa 100 1
19 SN 2007bd SN* 08 31 33.281 -01 11 57.98           SNIa 100 1
20 SN 2004gs SN* 08 38 23.179 +17 37 39.79     17.1     SNIa 77 1
21 SN 2008hv SN* 09 07 34.06 +03 23 32.1           SNIa-norm 96 1
22 SN 2005M SN* 09 37 32.76 +23 12 10.0     18.8     SNIa 91 1
23 SN 2008bc SN* 09 38 31.23 -63 58 25.6           SNIa 52 1
24 SN 2007S SN* 10 00 31.26 +04 24 26.2     16.7     SNIa 82 1
25 SN 2005ki SN* 10 40 28.220 +09 12 08.21           SNIa 100 1
26 SN 2012ht SN* 10 53 22.8 +16 46 35           SNIa-norm 84 1
27 SN 2007bc SN* 11 19 14.570 +20 48 32.51           SNIa 78 1
28 SN 2009aa SN* 11 23 42.28 -22 16 14.5           SNIa 33 1
29 SN 2006ax SN* 11 24 03.46 -12 17 29.2     17.1     SNIa 109 1
30 SN 2008bf SN* 12 04 02.878 +20 14 42.29           SNIa 74 2
31 SN 2007N SN* 12 49 01.25 -09 27 10.2     17.3     SNIap 49 1
32 SN 2006D SN* 12 52 33.87 -09 46 30.7           SNIa 107 1
33 SN 2011fe SN* 14 03 05.711 +54 16 25.22   10.12 10.06     SNIa-norm 747 1
34 SN 2007af SN* 14 22 21.03 -00 23 37.6     15.4     SNIa 185 1
35 SN 2013aa SN* 14 32 33.88 -44 13 27.8           SNIa 81 1
36 SN 2017cbv SN* 14 32 34.420 -44 08 02.74           SNIa 146 0
37 SN 2003du SN* 14 34 35.80 +59 20 03.8   13.46       SNIa 374 1
38 SN 2009Y SN* 14 42 23.68 -17 14 48.3           SNIa-norm 57 1
39 SN 2015bp SN* 15 05 28.1 +01 38 06           SNIa-norm 39 0
40 SN 2007ba SN* 15 16 42.629 +07 23 47.80           SNIap 63 1
41 SN 2005cf SN* 15 21 33.12 -07 26 57.1   13.54       SNIa 301 1
42 SN 2004eo SN* 20 32 54.19 +09 55 42.7   15.07 17.8     SNIa 225 1
43 SN 2004ey SN* 21 49 07.81 +00 26 39.2     16.0     SNIa 78 1
44 SN 2005kc SN* 22 34 07.34 +05 34 06.3     18.2     SNIa 89 1
45 SN 2006bh SN* 22 40 16.10 -66 29 06.3     14.8     SNIa 65 1
46 SN 2004ef SN* 22 42 10.020 +19 59 39.88           SNIa 107 1
47 SN 2007le SN* 23 38 48.45 -06 31 21.7     15.2     SNIa 139 1
48 SN 2005iq SN* 23 58 32.50 -18 42 33.0     17.2     SNIa 80 1

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2025MNRAS.540.3247S and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu