2026MNRAS.545f2075H


Query : 2026MNRAS.545f2075H

2026MNRAS.545f2075H - Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 545, part no 6, 2075 (2026/January-3)

Electron densities from [S II] lines significantly overestimate the impact of ionized AGN outflows.

HOLDEN L.R., SMITH D.J.B., ARNAUDOVA M.I., TADHUNTER C.N., RAMOS ALMEIDA C., SHENOY S., CEZAR P.H., DAS S. and BINU A.

Abstract (from CDS):

To explain the properties of the local galaxy population, theoretical models require active galactic nuclei (AGNs) to inject energy into host galaxies, thereby expelling outflows of gas that would otherwise form stars. Observational tests of this scenario rely on determining outflow masses, which requires measuring the electron density ($n_\mathrm{ e}$) of ionized gas. However, recent studies have argued that the most commonly used diagnostic may underestimate electron densities (and hence overestimate outflow masses) by several orders of magnitude, casting doubt as to whether ionized AGN-driven outflows can provide the impact needed to reconcile observations with theory. Here, we investigate this by applying two different electron-density diagnostics to Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) spectroscopy of the Quasar Feedback (QSOFEED) sample of 48 nearby type-2 quasars. Accounting for uncertainties, we find that outflow masses implied by the transauroral-line electron-density diagnostic are significantly lower than those produced by the commonly-used 'strong-line' [S II](6717/6731) method, indicating a different origin of these emission lines and suggesting that these doubts are justified. Nevertheless, we show that it is possible to modify the [S II](6717/6731) electron-density diagnostic for our sample by applying a correction of $\mathrm{log}_{10}(n_{e\mathrm{,\, outflow}}\mathrm{ [cm}^{-3}\mathrm{]}) = \mathrm{log}_{10}(n_{e\mathrm{,[S\, II]}}\mathrm{ [cm}^{-3}\mathrm{]}) + 0.75(\pm 0.07)$ to account for this, which results in values that are statistically consistent with those produced using the transauroral-line method. The techniques that we present here will be crucial for outflow studies in the upcoming era of large spectroscopic surveys, which will also be able to verify our results and broaden this method to larger samples of AGN of different types.

Abstract Copyright: © The Author(s) 2025. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of Royal Astronomical Society.

Journal keyword(s): ISM: clouds - ISM: jets and outflows - galaxies: active - galaxies: evolution - galaxies: ISM - galaxies: quasars: general

Simbad objects: 49

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 49
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 2MASS J00523062-0115484 Sy2 00 52 30.5991402888 -01 15 48.424590216   19.61 18.89     ~ 12 0
2 LEDA 1006913 Sy2 02 32 24.2519884272 -08 11 40.210282752   18.37 17.85     ~ 14 0
3 SDSS J073142.37+392623.7 Sy2 07 31 42.3821138616 +39 26 23.693023032   18.86 18.30     ~ 16 0
4 IRAS 07559+5058 Sy2 07 59 40.9648459968 +50 50 23.961198588   16.65 16.59     ~ 57 1
5 2MASS J08022433+4643008 Sy2 08 02 24.3420638712 +46 43 00.790904964   19.08 18.27     ~ 22 0
6 IRAS 07598+2601 Sy2 08 02 52.9271597616 +25 52 55.656029748   17.33 16.81     ~ 32 0
7 LEDA 3995110 Sy2 08 05 23.300 +28 18 15.70   18.55 18.05     ~ 24 0
8 2MASS J08184236+3604096 Sy2 08 18 42.3579955189 +36 04 09.694854255   18.41 18.00     ~ 17 0
9 SDSS J084135.09+010156.2 Sy2 08 41 35.0799957528 +01 01 56.237847456   18.83 18.22     ~ 37 0
10 2MASS J08581064+3121361 Sy2 08 58 10.6400635963 +31 21 36.223253530   19.01 18.36     ~ 14 0
11 LEDA 1892454 Sy2 09 15 44.1872469072 +30 09 22.115552760   18.83 18.02 16.202   ~ 26 0
12 3C 223.0 Sy2 09 39 52.7594046216 +35 53 58.922078496   19.51 18.60     ~ 279 0
13 IRAS 09425+1751 Sy2 09 45 21.3401384376 +17 37 53.252237208   20.85 20.09     ~ 65 1
14 2MASS J10104334+0612013 Sy2 10 10 43.3642763928 +06 12 01.383491808   18.45 17.87     ~ 42 1
15 LEDA 1179034 Sy2 10 15 36.2149720968 +00 54 59.328560268   18.73 18.02 17.152   ~ 26 0
16 2MASX J10165384+0028571 Sy2 10 16 53.825 +00 28 57.05   18.74 17.98     ~ 22 0
17 MCG+10-15-104 Sy2 10 34 08.54424 +60 01 52.1004   15.71 14.65     ~ 271 1
18 2dFGRS TGN427Z123 Sy2 10 36 00.3720693912 +01 36 53.601457356   18.22 17.59 15.837   ~ 19 0
19 LEDA 3469502 Sy2 11 00 12.3868783440 +08 46 16.287755052   17.84 17.38     ~ 42 1
20 7C 113440.70+613604.00 Sy2 11 37 21.3649586448 +61 20 01.132981764   18.83 18.23     ~ 42 1
21 LEDA 1377131 Sy2 11 52 45.6546787656 +10 16 23.811271392   17.94 17.57     ~ 21 0
22 2MASX J11575947+3707380 Sy2 11 57 59.5049830032 +37 07 38.293373604   18.79 18.05     ~ 16 0
23 LEDA 1964861 Sy2 12 00 41.3867157888 +31 47 46.187934756   18.63 17.95     ~ 23 0
24 2MASX J12183945+4706275 Sy2 12 18 39.4130008968 +47 06 27.676476108   21.68 20.49     ~ 45 0
25 SDSS J122341.46+080651.4 Sy2 12 23 41.4706485120 +08 06 51.393995748   19.19 18.58     ~ 15 0
26 LEDA 1365424 Sy2 12 38 43.4279753712 +09 27 36.604980360   18.10 17.41     ~ 58 0
27 LEDA 3384310 Sy2 12 41 36.2255780856 +61 40 43.358211660   17.95 17.58     ~ 18 0
28 2MASX J12440655+6529249 Sy2 12 44 06.6102163896 +65 29 25.263603384   19.08 18.47     ~ 13 0
29 LEDA 2816031 Sy2 13 00 38.0995253640 +54 54 36.824971176   18.22 17.90     ~ 25 0
30 2MASX J13163979+4452351 Sy2 13 16 39.7455052128 +44 52 35.060629584   17.83 17.45     ~ 54 0
31 PKS 1345+12 Sy2 13 47 33.36161873 +12 17 24.2398927   19.28 18.44 15.718   ~ 652 2
32 2dFGRS TGN203Z248 Sy2 13 56 17.7897665184 -02 31 01.511285376   19.23 18.60 17.333   ~ 14 0
33 SDSS J135646.10+102609.0 Sy2 13 56 46.106 +10 26 09.09   18.90 18.11     ~ 95 0
34 2MASS J14054122+4026325 Sy2 14 05 41.2164044760 +40 26 32.538517224   17.81 17.46     ~ 30 0
35 NAME Teacup AGN Sy2 14 30 29.8820644560 +13 39 12.007458684   16.89 16.64     ~ 82 0
36 LEDA 2344310 Sy2 14 36 07.2195012600 +49 28 58.586862036   18.87 18.18     ~ 16 0
37 7C 143530.19+302521.00 Sy2 14 37 37.8458706336 +30 11 01.060758708   18.62 18.09     ~ 23 1
38 Z 273-23 Sy2 14 40 38.0960806920 +53 30 15.961505184   16.05 15.03     ~ 341 1
39 LEDA 3096394 Sy2 14 55 19.4145210960 +32 26 01.735066212   18.58 18.19     ~ 18 0
40 LEDA 1270205 Sy2 15 09 04.2181476552 +04 34 41.766157380   18.90 18.27     ~ 30 0
41 2MASX J15170926+3353250 Sy2 15 17 09.240 +33 53 24.60   19.56 18.65     ~ 39 1
42 2MASS J15333802+3557081 Sy2 15 33 38.0328201216 +35 57 08.132038452   19.99 18.99     ~ 12 0
43 [VV2003c] J154832.4-010811 Sy2 15 48 32.3766205272 -01 08 11.769343980   18.18 17.87     ~ 11 0
44 LEDA 2061271 Sy2 15 58 29.3635421520 +35 13 28.653323880   19.26 18.61     ~ 19 0
45 2MASX J16243641+3344065 Sy2 16 24 36.3988125312 +33 44 06.702153612   19.22 18.64     ~ 18 0
46 IRAS 16511+2354 Sy2 16 53 15.0629382504 +23 49 43.063963572   18.25 17.80     ~ 52 0
47 IRAS F17130+5733 Sy2 17 13 50.3210892048 +57 29 54.875688720   18.44 17.77     ~ 30 0
48 IC 5063 Bla 20 52 02.15 -57 04 06.7   12.92 13.60 11.30   ~ 710 1
49 2MASX J21542576+1131300 Sy2 21 54 25.7453402520 +11 31 29.440429284   18.86 18.23     ~ 14 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2026MNRAS.545f2075H and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu